Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos, the beloved on-screen couple known for their playful banter and infectious chemistry, found themselves in a surprisingly heated discussion on Wednesday’s episode of Live with Kelly and Mark, and fans watching live were treated to a mix of humor, disbelief, and genuine emotion. The topic at hand? Girl Scout cookies – a seemingly innocent subject that unexpectedly ignited strong opinions between the longtime partners.
The conversation started after an official announcement revealed that the Girl Scouts would be discontinuing two of their most popular cookie flavors after the 2025 season: Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yay. While most people might have reacted with mild disappointment, the news clearly hit Mark differently. As Kelly began sharing the update with the audience, Mark’s eyes widened, and he leaned toward her with mock horror. “No, no! Do not — if it’s the Samoa, I’m going to walk off set right now,” he exclaimed, emphasizing his utter disbelief and his deep emotional attachment to the iconic Samoa cookies. The audience immediately erupted in laughter, sensing both his passion and his theatrical exaggeration.
Luckily for Mark, his beloved cookie choice wasn’t on the chopping block, meaning he didn’t need to follow through on his dramatic threat. However, the discussion didn’t end there. Kelly, ever the candid co-host, admitted her own surprise at the news, confessing that some of the fan-favorite flavors, including S’mores and Toast-Yay, were ones she hadn’t even heard of before. This sparked a quick, humorous exchange between the couple that only added to the lively energy of the show.
Mark, still in disbelief, asked, “Thin Mints?” – the universally adored classic. Kelly’s response caught both him and the audience off guard: “I don’t like Thin Mints.” The studio erupted in shock and playful outrage, and audience members booed her with good-natured disbelief. The contrast between Mark’s passionate cookie love and Kelly’s unexpected indifference made for an unforgettable television moment.
Throughout the segment, it became clear that what might have seemed like a trivial topic – cookies – could spark a playful yet intense debate, showcasing the unique dynamic that fans have come to adore. Kelly and Mark’s ability to turn even the simplest conversation into entertaining television once again proved why their chemistry resonates with viewers. While the news about discontinued cookies might have disappointed many Girl Scout fans, the lighthearted drama between the hosts provided a perfect mix of humor, surprise, and relatable reactions.
By the end of the segment, both Kelly and Mark had laughed at themselves and each other, making it clear that, for all their differences in cookie preferences, their camaraderie and humor remain the true stars of Live with Kelly and Mark. The audience, still chuckling and shaking their heads, left the show reminded that sometimes the smallest topics – even cookies – can spark the biggest reactions.